From COVID-19 conspiracy theories to confusion on the facts about Medicare and Medicaid to refusing to say that vaccines aren’t linked to autism, Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s February affirmation hearings on Capitol Hill have been something however clean for somebody who’s hoping to guide the Division of Well being and Human Companies.
Whereas his historical past of anti-vaccine remarks was a serious speaking level all through the hearings, his beliefs have been additionally entrance and middle throughout a heated alternate through which Sen. Angela Alsobrooks (D-Md.) brought up a remark that Kennedy as soon as made about vaccinations and the Black neighborhood.
In 2021, Kennedy had said, “We shouldn’t be giving Black folks the identical vaccine schedule that’s given to whites, as a result of their immune system is best than ours.”
Alsobrooks requested Kennedy to elucidate what he meant by that comment, and he went on to reference a “sequence of research” whereas saying analysis reveals that “Blacks want fewer antigens.” (For the document, consultants say that this is not true.)
“Proper now, how vaccine schedules are tailor-made is predicated on issues like your age, your publicity threat, you probably have different continual underlying well being situations ― however race isn’t considered one of them, and there isn’t analysis that means that it needs to be,” Joel Bervell, a latest medical graduate and medical myth-buster on social media, advised HuffPost.
What particularly bothered Bervell about Kennedy’s alternate with Alsobrooks was the truth that he doubled down on his remark from 2021.
Kennedy may have used this as a possibility to confess that he must do extra analysis and perceive the vaccine schedule, “however as an alternative, he defended what he mentioned, which I feel, for me, that’s the place the issue lies in,” Bervell advised HuffPost. “Not essentially the actual fact of the misinformation is on the market, however the truth that he wasn’t keen to not less than confront it or admit that onstage.”
Under, consultants like Bervell share their issues about Kennedy’s assertion and the way it displays a bigger problematic image:
Kennedy’s remark will be thought of ‘scientific racism,’ consultants say.
“In drugs, in science, we all know that race is a social assemble, that means that you would be able to’t have a look at somebody’s genes and establish what race they’re,” Bervell mentioned.
Meaning variations in vaccine timelines simply don’t make scientific sense.
“The remark that [Kennedy] made in regards to the vaccine schedule, it’s mainly scientific racism, which has been debunked,” Dr. Oni Blackstock, a main care and HIV doctor who’s the founder and government director of Health Justice, a racial and well being fairness consulting firm, advised HuffPost.
“He’s actually perpetuating this false perception that Black individuals are in some way biologically totally different from white folks and, in that method, justifying differential and finally unequal remedy for Black folks versus white folks,” Blackstock added.
“By saying that, he was placing on one of many bigger levels in well being care this notion that race-based drugs ought to nonetheless exist, when that’s really what many scientists not too long ago have been attempting to root out,” Bervell mentioned.
Race-based drugs and scientific racism has led to undertreatment of Black sufferers, dismissal of ache and even dying, Blackstock harassed.
Each consultants pointed to real-life examples of this, just like the false belief that Black people have better-functioning kidneys than white folks. This made it more durable for Black folks to get the remedy they wanted, like kidney transplants, in keeping with Bervell. And this thought sample isn’t from some faraway time ― a medical equation that bolstered this bias wasn’t modified till 2021, Bervell mentioned.
What’s extra, throughout the 1793 yellow fever epidemic in Philadelphia, Black folks have been believed to be proof against yellow fever, which was not true and led to excessive mortality charges amongst Black folks, Blackstock defined.
“The significance of understanding the issue with the myths is that they will actually result in laws being written into drugs that deal with populations in another way simply based mostly on race,” Bervell mentioned. “It might probably really change the care that folks obtain.”
Whereas it’s straightforward to have a look at a selected viewpoint as a one-off, medical racism has real-world penalties that irresponsible feedback could make worse. Selling debunked beliefs “distracts us from actually doing the work that we have to do, which is dismantling systemic racism in well being care and making certain that everybody has equitable entry to preventive care and coverings that they want,” Blackstock added.
Anna Moneymaker through Getty Photos
Such stances might result in extra distrust within the well being care system.
“One factor that can be form of unusual about him [Kennedy] is he’s somebody who for a very long time has mentioned that he doesn’t support vaccines,” Bervell mentioned. “Apparently, now he’s modified his thoughts, however for a very long time he mentioned he hasn’t supported vaccines, after which he’s additionally saying that Black folks ought to get a distinct vaccine schedule. So you must marvel, what’s your purpose in saying that in case you don’t even consider in vaccines?”
Bervell mentioned feedback like these from Kennedy can sow vaccine hesitancy within the Black inhabitants, which is harmful and may erode belief in evidence-based drugs.
It’s not the primary time that this has occurred, both, Blackstock added. In 2021, Kennedy produced a documentary known as “Medical Racism: The New Apartheid,” which Blackstock mentioned promoted misinformation about well being and vaccines to the Black neighborhood, together with different marginalized teams.
“It’s attention-grabbing how a few of his efforts have been centered on profiting from [and] exploiting the distrust that some within the Black neighborhood have round vaccines and the well being care system due to structural racism and medical racism,” Blackstock mentioned.
With misinformation and scare techniques rampant on social media, misinformation from authorities leaders will solely make it more durable to inform what’s actual and what’s pretend in drugs. Belief must be paramount for well being care as an establishment, Bervell mentioned.
“The belief is already eroded in well being care,” Bervell defined. “We have to have somebody that’s going to work with scientists, researchers, docs which can be on the bottom seeing these issues day-after-day, not somebody that’s in an ivory tower watching from above with out understanding of what’s really taking place on the bottom.”
Specialists say this rhetoric aligns with messaging from Donald Trump.
Blackstock harassed that whereas such false beliefs are very problematic, they monitor with a lot of the messaging from Donald Trump and his new presidential administration.
“It echoes a few of the rhetoric that [Trump] has shared round eugenics and immigrants,” Blackstock mentioned. “He’s talked about immigrants having ‘bad genes’ or ‘poisoning the blood of our country.’ It simply speaks to this concept of racial purity or genetic purity, and this false concept that sure teams of individuals are inherently inferior or predisposed to sure behaviors due to their genetics.”
And, once more, race is a social assemble and doesn’t equal genetic variations. “It’s simply actually stunning that within the yr 2025 we’re nonetheless coping with these beliefs being propagated which have been round for a number of centuries which have been used to justify slavery, used to justify inequitable remedy, used to justify pressured sterilization,” Blackstock mentioned.
Go Advert-Free — And Defend The Free Press
Already contributed? Log in to hide these messages.
Blackstock added that she thinks people get away with this type of rhetoric as a result of folks turn into accustomed to outlandish feedback and unhealthy habits.
“However we have to actually flag this and say that is actually harmful and actually regarding rhetoric that may have actual well being implications,” Blackstock mentioned.
